11 Best Places Where To Sell Beanie Babies For Cash (2024)

This article may contain links from our partners. Please read how we make money for more info.

In this article, I’ll walk you through some great places to sell your Beanie Babies and help you find the perfect buyers who’ll love these little plushies just as much as you do.

Whether you have a super rare, limited edition Beanie Baby or just a bunch of well-loved favorites, these platforms offer something for all collectors.

Let’s dive in and turn your nostalgic treasures into cash and teach you how to flip your stuff!

Quick Picks

These are the two best selling sites I’ve used that reach a large amount of potential buyers:

• Best Overall Selling Platform – eBay
• Free Selling Site – Facebook Marketplace

11 Best Places Where To Sell Beanie Babies

1. eBay

If you’re wondering where to sell your Beanie Babies online, eBay is an excellent platform to consider.

As one of the most well-established marketplaces on the internet, eBay boasts a massive user base of collectors actively seeking rare and unique items of all kinds.

I’ve used it for years to sell electronics and old sports gear, so I know the ins and outs of selling on eBay. People sell a variety of collectible and rare Beanie Babies, plus other plushies.

With eBay, you can set up auctions and see if people rack up the price, or you can set it for “buy now” so stuff sells fast. I tend to go for the auctions if what I’m selling is a hot item.

If you want to reach more buyers, create a detailed listing that describes your Beanies’ good condition and rarity.

I searched for ‘TY Beanie Babies” to get an idea of prices. Don’t forget to use the filters or use the Beanie Baby tag to look up specific items.

So, if I were you and had some plushies sitting around, I’d see what those Beanie Babies are worth.

2. Craigslist

Craigslist is great for connecting with buyers in your local community, so you can avoid shipping costs and sell your collection in person.

Plus, posting your collection on Craigslist is a breeze thanks to the user-friendly interface and straightforward posting system.

I love Craigslist because you don’t have to pay any fees for listing or selling, but things may sit around a bit longer, or people may lowball some offers.

One of the best things about using Craigslist is that interested buyers can contact you directly through the website. No need to swap email addresses or anything like back in my day!

When using Craigslist, it’s important to be safe. If I’m meeting buyers in public, I bring a friend or family member or meet at a busy grocery store.

3. Facebook Marketplace

I’ve sold a few things on Facebook Marketplace, and I like how easy it was to list our daughter’s old toys and clothes for sale.

If you want to sell online without fees, Facebook Marketplace is the best way to sell for free.

Facebook Marketplace makes it easy to advertise your collection to your Facebook network of friends, family, and other Facebook members.

Plus, Facebook Messenger allows for fast communication between buyers and sellers, making it easy to answer questions and negotiate prices.

You can post up to ten photos of your Beanie Babies, write a detailed description of their condition and rarity, and set your asking price.

On Facebook, you can see buyers’ profiles and check if they’re potential scammers. This can help you feel more comfortable selling to strangers.

4. Etsy

Starting an Etsy store is the perfect place to sell these valuable toys to an audience that values their craftsmanship, history, and sentimental value.

One of the great things about selling on Etsy is its community of buyers who appreciate the art of collecting vintage items and pay extra for interesting finds.

They’re looking for items with character and personality, and your Beanie Baby might be just the collectible toy they’re searching for.

I sell printables in a shop rather than collectibles, but the process for sales is still the same. You’ll need to:

• Create an Etsy seller account
• Start an Etsy Shop
• Upload photos
• Write a detailed description of each Beanie Baby

5. OfferUp

OfferUp is a mobile-friendly platform designed for buying and selling items within local communities, making it a convenient place to sell to interested buyers nearby.

It’s mainly known for selling used clothes, but its collectibles section is becoming popular now that flea market flipping is booming.

When creating your listing, include all relevant information, such as the name of the Beanie Baby, its condition, and any unique features it may have.

Also, consider pricing your items competitively. Research what your Beanie Baby is selling for on OfferUp or other platforms to understand how to price yours.

6. Sell4Value

As an online service that buys Beanie Babies and other collectibles, Sell4Value provides an easy way to get bulk funds for your plush toys.

Sell4Value is an excellent option for quickly selling a large collection of common Beanies.

The company buys thousands of plush toys every month for $0.40 – $0.50 per toy, depending on the size of your collection.

A smart strategy would be to sell a common Beanie Baby on Sell4Value and post a rare Beanie Baby on eBay (hopefully with the original Tush tag intact).

7. Bonanza

Bonanza is an online marketplace focusing on unique items, including vintage toys and collectibles like Beanie Babies.

One of the most convenient features of Bonanza is its seamless integration with other marketplaces such as eBay, Etsy, and Amazon.

If you already have listings on one of these sites, importing them into Bonanza is a quick and easy way to expand your reach and attract more potential buyers.

This feature also helps diversify your options and increase your chances of selling.

In addition to its integration feature, Bonanza is a great platform to sell Beanies because of its broad customer base and diverse product offerings.

8. Mercari

Selling your Beanies on Mercari is a breeze. All you need to do is snap a few clear and well-lit photos of your Beanie Baby, provide some details about its condition, and upload it to the app.

Once your listing is live, interested buyers can view your Beanie Baby and make an offer.

If someone decides to purchase your item, you’ll receive a notification on the app, and you can counteroffer or accept what they’re offering.

Once you’re happy with the money, Mercari will handle the payment processing on your behalf.

From there, all you need to do is pack and ship the item within three days, and Mercari will credit the payment to your account once the buyer confirms receipt.

9. Ruby Lane

Ruby Lane is an online marketplace specializing in antiques, vintage items, and collectibles with a touch of nostalgia, making it an ideal place to sell collectibles.

The platform’s focus on high-quality items appeals to serious collectors seeking the most valuable and rarest Beanie Babies.

Ruby Lane’s knowledgeable community and dedicated customer support ensure a smooth selling experience.

The site will help you showcase the unique qualities of your collection and connect with potential buyers who understand their worth.

10. Sell2BBNovelties

Sell2BBNoveltiesis a specialized platform that buys and sells Beanie Babies, Beanie Boos, and other collectible toys.

It offers a convenient way to sell collectibles for a reasonable price- though a rare or special Beanie Baby would sell for more, of course.

Sell2BBNovelties takes the hassle out of selling your Beanies individually and helps you sell your Beanie Baby collection to collectors who appreciate their value.

11. Flea Markets

Flea markets are an excellent option for local selling, as they attract a diverse audience of buyers interested in unique and collectible items.

Setting up a booth or table at a local flea market allows you to display your Beanie Baby in an environment where people actively browse for interesting finds.

Doing this can benefit those with Beanie Babies still with their original hang tags, as collectors often value these added details.

They’re inexpensive and provide a perfect opportunity to network with other collectors and enthusiasts, potentially leading to valuable connections and future sales.

FAQs

Can I actually make money selling Beanie Babies?

Yes, I see a lot of people making money selling Beanie Babies, especially if they have a sought-after rare Beanie Baby in their collection.

Specific Beanie Babies sell better depending on rarity, condition, and demand.

Collectors often pay a premium for a rare or special Beanie Baby in mint condition, with original tush tag, swing tag, hang tag, and limited production numbers.

You can actually check eBay for whatever beanies you have, and use the filter on the left side to see the “Sold” ones- giving you an idea of what yours will sell for.

Also, if you have other TY products like Beanie Buddies, Beanie Boos, and more, sell those to earn more money from plushies.

What’s the best place to sell several Beanie Babies?

For those looking to reach a global audience and sell many Beanie Babies for cash, online marketplaces like eBay, Facebook, Etsy, and Mercari are popular choices.

These platforms offer a wide reach, with millions of users every day, user-friendly interfaces, and easy-to-manage listings.

Selling locally may result in a quicker sale and eliminate shipping costs, but the final sale price for most Beanie Babies may be lower due to a smaller pool of buyers.

Some people sell their common Beanies at a garage sale for $1 each, which is a bit more than the prices on online sites.

What are the best-selling Beanie Babies right now?

Generally, the most popular collectible toys are those with limited production numbers, manufacturing errors, or unique features.

The best-selling Beanie Babies can change over time, depending on market trends, but there are a few popular stuffed animals consistently.

Here are some of the most valuable Beanie Babies:

1. Princess Bear – $500,000
2. Bubbles the Fish – $129,000
3. Picadilly Attic – $125,000
4. Batty – $125,000
5. Jolly the Walrus – $75,000
6. Lefty Donkey/Right Elephant – $50,000
7. Valentino Bear – $42,000

Final Thoughts

So, want to sell your Beanie Baby and see what cash you can get?

Sites like eBay and Facebook Marketplace are opening doors to sell your Beanie Babies and other collectibles or regular household items.

Remember to take high-quality photos, provide accurate descriptions, and price your items competitively.

Whether you’re looking to sell a few rare Beanie Babies or an entire collection, with the right approach, you can find the perfect buyers and make some extra money in the process.

So go ahead and dig out those old Beanie Babies from the closet and get those Beanie Babies sold! Good luck and happy selling!